Appliance Repair or Replace? Cost Calculator for Tampa Bay Homeowners
Find out in two minutes whether your repair quote makes sense, using the limits we apply on real service calls.
- Free service callwith any repair
- 2,486 jobsbehind these numbers, Sept 2025 – Aug 2026
- 90-day warrantyon parts and labor
Not sure it is worth fixing? Tell us what it is doing
We call back within 15 minutes – 8 AM to 7 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 6 PM on weekends
Quick answer: how to use this calculator
Three steps and a calculator. You need your repair quote and the price of a comparable new unit.
- 1. Get the replacement number
- Look up your appliance in the table below. The range is the real cost of a new unit in Tampa Bay: retail price, 7% sales tax, and delivery and haul-away or installation.
- 2. Divide your quote by it
- Take the full repair quote, parts and labor, and compare it with the total replacement cost of a comparable new unit. Up to 50% of that number, repair. Around 50%, it is a close call and the choice is yours. Above 60%, we say buy new.
- 3. Check the condition
- Condition matters more than the year on the data plate. A sound cabinet, tub and insulation make a machine a repair candidate; structural rust or flood exposure do not.
Got a quote and not sure about it? Tell us the appliance, brand and what it is doing
The service call is free with any repair. We call back within 15 minutes – 8 AM to 7 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 6 PM on weekends
Repair-or-replace limits by appliance, in dollars
The limits below are 50% and 60% of the total replacement cost of a new unit. Your own limit is your new unit’s price (with tax, delivery or installation) multiplied by 0.5 and 0.6.
| Appliance | Total replacement cost (new unit, 7% tax, delivery or install) | Repair makes sense up to (50%) | We advise replacing above (60%) | Our average labor ticket |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Refrigerator (French door) | $1,577 – $3,503 | $789 – $1,752 | $946 – $2,102 | $339 |
| Washer (full-size) | $562 – $1,364 | $281 – $682 | $337 – $818 | $259 |
| Dryer (full-size) | $635 – $1,577 | $318 – $789 | $381 – $946 | $270 |
| Dishwasher (24" built-in) | $520 – $1,697 | $260 – $849 | $312 – $1,018 | $213 |
| Wall oven (built-in) | $1,433 – $3,145 | $717 – $1,573 | $860 – $1,887 | $307 |
| Stove / range (30" freestanding) | $721 – $1,470 | $361 – $735 | $433 – $882 | $232 / $319 |
| Cooktop (30"–36") | $557 – $1,968 | $279 – $984 | $334 – $1,181 | $246 |
| Freezer (chest / upright) | $293 – $1,471 | $147 – $736 | $176 – $883 | $271 |
| Wine cooler | $541 – $1,898 | $271 – $949 | $325 – $1,139 | $344 |
| Ice maker (under-counter) | $503 – $3,289 | $252 – $1,645 | $302 – $1,973 | $302 |
The low end of each range is an entry-level new unit, the high end a full-featured one. The average labor ticket is labor only, without parts, across mass-market brands in our Workiz records. Sales tax is 7.5% in Hillsborough County and 7.0% in Pinellas, Manatee and Sarasota. Full method and sources: Repairing vs. Replacing Home Appliances in Tampa Bay.
Three worked examples
- A mid-range washer
- An $850 washer costs $990 with 7% tax and $80 for delivery and haul-away. Repair makes sense up to about $495, and above about $594 we advise buying new. Our average washer labor ticket is $259, so a drain pump, inlet valve or suspension fix usually sits well under half.
- A mid-range dishwasher
- A $650 dishwasher plus $45.50 tax and a $200 installation comes to $895.50. Fifty percent is about $448 and sixty percent about $537. With a $213 average labor ticket, a repair here is about 24% of the cost of replacing.
- A luxury refrigerator
- A new built-in Sub-Zero Designer Column runs $8,200–$10,800 before custom cabinetry work. Our average labor ticket on luxury refrigerators is $556, so even a major component repair is a small share of replacement. Under 15–20 years old, repairing is almost always the smarter move.
What the calculator does not see
- A sealed-system leak or failed compressor on an older budget refrigerator can push labor and parts past the 60% mark. That is the main refrigerator exception.
- A seized rear drum bearing or a corroded basket spider arm on a washer pushes the repair past 60% of a new unit. A drain pump, inlet valve or suspension rods do not.
- Small, cheap units. A $199 compact chest freezer should simply be replaced after a major failure; a full-size upright is worth repairing.
- Flood exposure. An appliance that stood in floodwater is a fire and shock hazard even when it runs again, and a refrigerator or freezer with wet foam insulation cannot be saved.
- Structural rust. If the frame or tub is rusted through, the percentage does not matter.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my appliance is worth repairing?
Add up the full repair quote and compare it with the total cost of a comparable new unit: price, sales tax, delivery or installation, and haul-away. Up to about 50% of that number, repairing makes financial sense. Around 50% we lay out both options and leave the decision with you. Above 60% we advise buying new.
How much does appliance repair cost in Tampa Bay?
In our 12-month records (2,486 service calls, September 2025 to August 2026), the average labor ticket for mass-market appliances was $270, excluding parts. By appliance it runs from $213 for dishwashers to $339 for refrigerators and $344 for wine coolers. Luxury brands average $612.
Does the age of my appliance matter?
Less than its condition. A ten-year-old washer with a solid tub and no shaft corrosion will often outlast a three-year-old budget machine with a cracked drum spider arm. We look at the cabinet, tub, wiring and hydraulics before the date on the data plate.
What sales tax should I add to a new appliance?
In 2026 the combined rate is 7.5% in Hillsborough County (Tampa) and 7.0% in Pinellas (Clearwater, St. Petersburg), Manatee (Bradenton) and Sarasota counties. Florida applies the county surtax to the first $5,000 of a single item.
Do you charge for the service call?
The service call is free with any repair.
Is it worth repairing a Sub-Zero, Wolf or Thermador?
Almost always, under 15–20 years old. A new Sub-Zero costs $8,200–$21,630 and a new Wolf range $12,000–$28,000, while our luxury average labor ticket is $612.
Customer Reviews
Not sure whether to repair or replace?
Free service call with any repair. We take same-day calls across Tampa, Clearwater, St. Petersburg, Sarasota and Bradenton, 8 AM to 7 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 6 PM on weekends.
Andrew Teodor
Nataliya Teodor
Sem Green
John Goldin